Mets & Reds

Submitted by: LetsGoMetsLGM

Mets

NameAgeLevelP1P2AvailabilityYearsAFVSalarySurplusLowMedianHigh
Sonny Gray31MajorsSPLow250.522.228.322.628.334
Eugenio Suarez29Majors3BMedium426.935.8-8.9-10.7-8.9-7.1

Total Value:

19.4

Reds

NameAgeLevelP1P2AvailabilityYearsAFVSalarySurplusLowMedianHigh
David Peterson26MinorsSPMedium412.98.54.43.54.45.3
Mark VientosMinors3B15.412.315.418.5

Total Value:

19.8

Challenger

LetsGoMetsLGM, Did you decide the Mets could use Gray and Suarez (you're probably right!) and then just add the numbers to get a close match on what you want to trade to the Reds? Okay for a starting point, but to get a legitimate trade, you need to at least try to address the needs of the Reds. They have good young starting pitchers, but lack OF's, 1 experienced relief pitcher who can get induce ground balls and have good strike out numbers, and they need an experienced (backup) catcher behind Stephenson who can at least hit his weight. I've thought about McNeil, but the Reds really need a CFer they can build around. I don't know if the Reds and Mets are a good trade match.

LetsGoMetsLGM

The Reds have Lodolo and Greene, but Peterson would provide solid depth and a solid young arm for an aging, oft-injured pitcher who is about to become a free agent. Vientos is the heir apparent to Votto, so he fits perfectly, and would do serious damage in your ballpark. The Mets have traded 3 CF prospects in the last 3 years. They are out. If the Reds have to have a CF in this deal, the Mets are not the best fit.

NEWSLETTER? SURE, SIGN ME UP!