It wouldn't be done in isolation. I thought of this with the reports that the Cubs showed interest in Bregman and the Phillies were inquiring about Imai. Also the indications art that Crawford will be getting a spot in the OF. Crawford and Marsh are redundant players to have in the same lineup. Neither bring plus power, through Marsh clearly has more power. Both have speed and athleticism that let them play CF, but neither are a CFer. I don't see a Crawford, insert CF, and Marsh combo in the OF working from a production standpoint. Shaw did have some growing pains last year but still looks to be a 20/20 guy with a better glove than what the Phillies have at third, and projection to be much more. He'd bring some balance with a RH bat (hit 6 of his 13 hr in 100AB vs LHP) and is only 24. People are high on Miller and saying he can step in for Bohm if they trade him this offseason, but Shaw put up even better numbers and was rated higher.