Guardians & Rays

Submitted by: ms1213

Guardians

NameAgeLevelP1P2AvailabilityYearsAFVSalarySurplusLowMedianHigh
Yandy Diaz32Majors1BLow2.439.725.214.511.614.517.4
Amed Rosario28MajorsSSOFMedium0.42.30.61.71.41.72.1

Total Value:

16.2

Rays

NameAgeLevelP1P2AvailabilityYearsAFVSalarySurplusLowMedianHigh
Brayan Rocchio23MajorsSS5.436.515.421.116.821.125.3
Kahlil Watson21MinorsSS0005.74.55.76.9

Total Value:

26.8

You found a premium feature!

Want an ad-free experience, with access to our premium features, like the Team Rankings, GM Override, Player Rankings, and Future Trade/Free Agent/Extension Values Graphs?

General Manager Badge
ms1213

Shows as an overpay but hear me out.... Cleveland gets 2 players they are familiar with to contribute to the playoff run. Diaz gives a power bat they desperately need, Rosario can hold down the fort for now at Shortstop like he did in 2022. Rocchio needs a change of scenery and I feel that most teams give him a value around 12, 21 seems super high, Watson is blocked with all the MI talent the Guardians have and is worth it for Tampa as he is a former 1st rounder.

General Manager Badge
ShaquilleOatmeal

I assumed with Naylor and Manzardo, that they would not need a 1B/DH. You think they'd really be in the market for a 1B?

General Manager Badge
SportsCoach

They are in the market for a two or 5 hole hitter... Diaz fits that... They badly need a hitter and a SP... Trust me outside of C, LF and 3B they will be willing to acquire someone of any other position as long as it fills that need they have with the bat..

General Manager Badge
SportsCoach

I'll be honest... This is 100% no from Cleveland... They aren't gonna trade for Rosario...

General Manager Badge
mp2891

Because of a personality clubhouse culture problem? Seems weird you'd take such a hard line on someone valued at $1.7MM.

General Manager Badge
SportsCoach

Naw, Rosario is good in the clubhouse... It's the fact he was already essentially cut by Cleveland and if they wanted him, they would have outbid the Rays for him without a doubt... They aren't gonna get him back when they cut him...

NEWSLETTER? SURE, SIGN ME UP!